tiergain
PickyStory vs Tiergain in 2026: deal pickers or full bundle control
PickyStory groups products into deals and lets customers pick. That works until you need dollar thresholds, sequential navigation, or combined rewards in a single tier. Here is where the two apps split.
Quick Verdict
PickyStory covers bundles, kits, and looks with a deal-picker model, but caps out at 4 bundle types and locks combined rewards behind higher plans - Tiergain ships 10+ architectures with discount, free shipping, and free gift stacking on every plan.
What is PickyStory?
PickyStory (now rebranded as Amplify) is a Shopify bundle and upsell app. It supports bundles as products, bundle builders, quantity breaks, BOGO, mix-and-match, and frequently bought together. With a 4.6 rating across 533 reviews, it covers broad upsell scenarios. Pricing is $99.50/month on a pay-as-you-grow model for stores up to $30k/month in revenue, with a 30-day free trial. It is not Built for Shopify certified.
Where PickyStory Falls Short
Broad but shallow bundle types
PickyStory covers bundles, kits, BOGO, and quantity breaks, but lacks custom architectures like subscription boxes, meal builders, gift set builders, or starter kit + refills patterns. Stores with complex catalogs that need structured multi-step flows hit the ceiling fast.
Combined rewards not available
Each deal applies one reward type. You cannot stack a percentage discount with free shipping and a free gift in the same tier. Merchants who run tiered promotions - "buy 3 get 10% off, buy 5 get 15% off + free shipping" - cannot build that in PickyStory.
Revenue-based pricing at $99.50/month
PickyStory charges $99.50/month on a pay-as-you-grow model for stores up to $30k/month in revenue. As your store grows past that threshold, your bill grows with it. That is 2x to 6x more than Tiergain flat-rate plans for the same bundle features.
No dollar-based thresholds
All deal triggers are product or quantity based. You cannot set "spend $100 to unlock free shipping" or "add $75 more for a bonus gift." B2B and luxury stores that sell fewer high-ticket items get no spend-based mechanics.
Limited navigation modes
Customers see all deal products at once. There is no sequential step-by-step mode where buyers pick a base product, then add-ons, then extras. Flat product grids drop conversion on stores with 30+ SKUs per deal.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
| Feature | PickyStory | Tiergain |
|---|---|---|
| Bundle type variety | Bundles, kits, BOGO, quantity breaks | 10+ architectures, fully customizable |
| Combined rewards | Single reward per deal | Discount + free shipping + free gift |
| Dollar thresholds | No | Yes, quantity or dollar |
| Sequential + free-flow | Free-flow only | Both modes |
| Guided kit builder | No | Yes, multi-step |
| Shop the Look | Yes, native deal type | Yes, within bundle flow |
| BOGO support | Yes | Yes |
| Theme customization | Basic color and layout | 20+ controls, live preview |
| Mobile-first design | Responsive | Mobile-first |
| Works with all themes | Most themes | All themes, no code |
| Flat-rate pricing | No, revenue-based | Yes |
| Inventory sync | Yes | Yes |
| Tiered volume discounts | Basic quantity breaks | Advanced tiers with combined rewards |
Why Merchants Switch to Tiergain
AOV lifted 31% with combined rewards
A fashion merchant ran "buy 3 scarves, get 12% off + free shipping" in Tiergain. PickyStory only allowed the discount. Adding free shipping as a second incentive lifted AOV from $64 to $84 in the first 21 days.
App cost dropped $50/month on flat pricing
A home decor store doing $25k/month in revenue paid $99.50/month on PickyStory. Tiergain Pro at $50/month gave them the same bundle capabilities. That is $50/month back in margin, $600/year saved.
Sequential kits pushed items per order from 1.6 to 3.1
A supplements store switched deal grids for Tiergain sequential builders. Customers stepped through "pick your protein, pick your greens, pick your extras." Items per order nearly doubled in 14 days.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I migrate my PickyStory deals to Tiergain?
Yes. You can recreate your existing deals as Tiergain bundles. Most merchants finish in under an hour. Your product associations and discount rules carry over without downtime.
How does Tiergain pricing compare to PickyStory?
Tiergain uses flat-rate pricing: Free / $15 / $50 / $150 per month. PickyStory charges $99.50/month for stores up to $30k/month in revenue, and scales up from there. Even Tiergain Enterprise at $150/month costs less than PickyStory for most stores.
Does Tiergain support Shop the Look like PickyStory?
Yes. You can build shoppable looks within Tiergain bundle flows. The difference is you can combine looks with tiered discounts, free shipping rewards, and sequential navigation - none of which PickyStory supports in look-type deals.
How long does Tiergain setup take?
Most merchants go live with their first bundle in 15 minutes. Install from the Shopify App Store, pick a bundle architecture, set your rules, publish. No developer needed.
Can I run dollar-based thresholds with Tiergain?
Yes. Set spend thresholds like "spend $100+ to unlock 15% off" or "add $50 more for free shipping." PickyStory only supports quantity-based triggers. Tiergain supports both quantity and dollar thresholds.
Does Tiergain work with my current Shopify theme?
Yes. Tiergain uses a Theme App Extension that works with every Shopify theme. No code edits, no Liquid changes, no developer required.
Ready to switch from PickyStory?
Free plan available. No credit card required.